Home

Who is Responsible for Yoga Teaching & Training Competency? What Standards Must Be Met? + Influential Teachers Not Registered with YA

Please Note: This is part of a series of related topics. Use the quick menu above to navigate within this section.

Overview

Yoga is a Self-Regulated Field

  • Yoga is not a government-regulated occupation. Yoga is a self-regulated field.
  • Up until recently, no organization has specified minimum competency standards for widespread adoption among yoga professionals.
  • There has been a widespread misperception that Yoga Alliance contributes to the field’s self-regulation by upholding competency standards. That is not correct.
  • The level of competency that an individual yoga teacher achieves after a training is the responsibility of the trainer and the trainee only.

Self-Regulation Proposals

As a result of no widely accepted standards and a commercialization of teacher trainings, we see a glut of unprepared teachers — some incapable of transmitting yoga teachings with skill and wisdom. This has prompted many yoga professionals to search for remedies in an effort to uplift the field as a whole. As part of this effort, we offer the following as a remedy for the lack of widely-adopted standards for yoga professionals:

  • We recognize and support Mark Whitwell’s recommended standards for yoga teachers (detailed here). Those offer a comprehensive perspective of yoga teaching as a whole.
  • We provide and support specific Minimum Knowledge Standards.

Background

  1. Yoga is not a government-regulated occupation. Yoga is a self-regulated field. For more information, see Frequently Asked Questions here.
  2. There’s a widespread misperception that Yoga Alliance contributes to the field’s self-regulation by upholding competency standards. In fact, Yoga Alliance does not propose, assess, certify or enforce competency standards, nor does it provide meaningful resources to encourage greater competency. This did not change with the new requirements that took effect February 2020.
  3. If a trainee is held to any competency standards at all, those standards are specified and upheld by the trainer and/or a particular certification process such as Iyengar or Ashtanga.
  4. There’s an implication that newly trained teachers who have completed a training “approved” by Yoga Alliance have achieved a particular standard level of competency. For example, a hiring manager might presume that a “graduate” of a Yoga Alliance “approved” training (RYS) has a proven ability to sequence effectively and promote student safety, to understand scope of practice, to be skilled in biomechanics and the physiology of stretching and so on. However, no such standards are required or verified by Yoga Alliance. The quality of training and level of competency achieved by a trainee are unrelated to Yoga Alliance.

Scroll down for more detail on these points.


YA Does Not Assess Competency

Since launching its registry in 1999, Yoga Alliance has never assessed or certified competency of teachers or trainers (which they call “schools”).

Yoga Alliance recognizes teachers and trainers based on two things: paperwork and payment of fees. In return, teachers and trainers are given “registry marks.”

YA “Approved” Studio Churning Out Teachers So Poorly Prepared That the Studio Looks Elsewhere to Hire Teachers

A few months ago a student who had gone through my teacher training called me looking for advice for an upcoming teaching “audition.” She told me of a Craigslist ad that a local studio had posted looking for qualified teachers. You might wonder why I thought it was odd to learn about this ad. It’s because this studio offers their own 200, 300 and 500-hour training programs and regularly churns out teachers like gum balls out of a machine. The point? Their program is so bad that they won’t even hire their own trainees! But the studio trainers are YA-accredited so they keep bringing in trainees who don’t know any better, taking their money and running trainings with a sub-par curriculum.  This is a big and reputable studio – I kid you not. I’ve got lots of stories that would make you go… huh, really? – Teacher Trainer

As of October 12, 2019, Yoga Alliance had a page on their website entitled “Spirit of the Standards July 2016” (as shown in the screenshot below). Please read it for yourself:

Those “Standards Guidelines” lack specificity and are strangely and obscurely written.

    • The implication from the title is that Yoga Alliance is advocating for teaching competency standards.
    • But in fact the “Standards Guidelines” listed here are nothing more than saying the trainer needs to be registered with Yoga Alliance (which, again, means paperwork and fees) and that they submit a curriculum organized into five categories.
    • This sentence,  “All standards for a RYS are intended to be clear, implementable reflections of the above criteria.” appears to be circular reasoning (defined as a logical fallacy of assuming what it is attempting to provide, or creating a circle in reasoning where no useful information is being shared).
    • Isn’t the bulleted list supposed to define standards?
    • How are “all standards” and the “above criteria” different and what are they talking about?
    • Could this mean that the organization has changed the expected meaning of the word “standards” midway to mean a fluid definition that is created by each trainer, not Yoga Alliance? This page of “standards” is beyond comprehension.

The 2020 Changes Still Did Not Introduce Standards

The new  requirements that took effect February 2020 require trainers to assess competency — of unspecified standards — on more than 50 topics while offering insignificant resources to support the new requirements.

    1. The new Yoga Alliance requirements that took effect February 2020 specify 13 “competency areas” which are simply broad subjects such as Asana, Anatomy and History.
    2. They then put bullet points beneath these subjects with such phrases as “historical context,” “sequencing,” “pace” and “environment” — which are not standards. They’re topics.
    3. Thus, it’s a verifiable fact that Yoga Alliance does not propose, assess, certify or enforce standards.

Rather, Yoga Alliance requires trainers to submit an application and, as of February 2020, additional documentation that attests to the fact that they, the trainers, will be assessing competency.

    1. The new requirements are deemed to have been met or not met before any trainings have been held.
    2. Thus, the changes which are widely assumed to be “standards” are not actually standards but an extensive application form that requires not only “accounting for every training hour” but also submitting the school’s intellectual property to Yoga Alliance!
Topics Are Not Standards

Trainer & Trainee Due Diligence

My feeling is that it is the responsibility of the TRAINER and their respective YTT offering to insure benchmarks are in place and the responsibility of the prospective TRAINEE to do their due diligence. I know many trainers who have only taught yoga for a few years who begin a YTT, pay their dues to YA and boom… they’re off and running and counting the money in the bank. In these cases, they give substandard trainings and then disappear a few years later, not having established credibility in the field. My priority is creating a safe, quality standalone YTT without the approval of anyone except my own board and governing body, which in my case is with the endorsement and teaching of Registered Nurses, Advanced Practice Nurses, Doctorate Nurses and other recognized expert medical professionals. – Annette Tersigni, The Yoga Nurse  link


Many Teachers Not Registered with YA

There are many highly recognized, influential teachers who are not registered with Yoga Alliance. This does not imply anything about the teachers registered with YA but instead demonstrates that registration is not required nor does it directly correlate with skill, experience or influence.

The following teachers, for example, were not on the registry as of the date noted. The information below was gathered using the teacher search function on the Yoga Alliance website which returned results as in this screenshot from Oct 3, 2019:

Sampling of Influential Teachers NOT Registered with Yoga Alliance

    1. Benagh, Barbara
    2. Blossom, Scott
    3. Boccio, Frank Jude
    4. Brower, Elena
    5. Cope, Stephen
    6. Dass, Ram
    7. Farhi, Donna
    8. Farmer, Angela
    9. Finger, Alan
    10. Folan, Lilias
    11. Freeman, Richard
    12. Gannon, Sharron
    13. Gates, Rolf
    14. Holleman, Dona
    15. Kaivalya, Alanna
    16. Kaminoff, Leslie
    17. Kest, Bryan
    18. Khalsa, Gurmukh Kaur
    19. LePage, Joseph
    20. Life, David
    21. McGonigal, Kelly
    22. Miller, Elise Browning
    23. Miller, Tim
    24. Mittra, Dharma
    25. Mohan, A.G.
    26. Nelson, Sonia
    27. Paul, Russill
    28. Ray, Kali
    29. Raye, Saul David
    30. Ross, Steve
    31. Schiffmann, Erich
    32. Schumacher, John
    33. Stern, Eddie
    34. Swenson, David
    35. Vernon, Rama Jyoti
    36. Walden, Patricia
    37. White, Ganga

Benagh, Barbara

    • Not Registered on Oct 3, 2019
    • TheYogaStudio.org Not Registered on Oct 3, 2019
    • 17 teachers in the registry noted Barbara Benagh in their bio

Blossom, Scott

    • Not Registered on Oct 3, 2019
    • Shunyata Yoga Not Registered on Oct 3, 2019
    • 16 teachers in the registry noted Scott Blossom in their bio

Boccio, Frank Jude

    • Not Registered on Oct 3, 2019
    • 5 teachers in the registry noted Frank Jude Boccio in their bio

Brower, Elena

    • Not Registered on Oct 3, 2019
    • 29 teachers in the registry noted Elena Brower in their bio

Cope, Stephen

    • Not Registered on Oct 3, 2019
    • 12 teachers in the registry noted Stephen Cope in their bio

Dass, Ram

    • Not Registered on Oct 3, 2019
    • 15 teachers in the registry noted Ram Dass in their bio

Farhi, Donna

    • Not Registered on Oct 3, 2019
    • 64 teachers in the registry noted Donna Farhi in their bio

Farmer, Angela

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 31 teachers in the registry noted Angela Farmer in their bio

Finger, Alan

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 43 teachers in the registry noted Alan Finger in their bio

Folan, Lilias

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 18 teachers in the registry noted Lilias Folan in their bio

Freeman, Richard

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 91 teachers in the registry noted Richard Freeman in their bio

Gannon, Sharron

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • Jivamukti Yoga Not Registered on Oct 3, 2019
    • 163 teachers in the registry noted Jivamukti Yoga in their bio
    • 65 teachers in the registry noted Sharron (or Sharon) Gannon in their bio

Gates, Rolf

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 69 teachers in the registry noted Rolf Gates in their bio

Holleman, Dona

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 9 teachers in the registry noted Dona (or Donna) Holleman in their bio

Kaivalya, Alanna

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 15 teachers in the registry noted Alanna Kaivalaya in their bio

Kaminoff, Leslie

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 100 teachers in the registry noted Leslie Kaminoff in their bio

Kest, Bryan

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 94 teachers in the registry noted Bryan Kest in their bio

Khalsa, Gurmukh Kaur

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 15 teachers in the registry noted Gurmukh Kaur Khalsa in their bio

Le Page, Joseph

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 17 teachers in the registry noted Joseph LePage in their bio

Life, David

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • Jivamukti Yoga Not Registered on Oct 3, 2019
    • 163 teachers in the registry noted Jivamukti Yoga in their bio
    • 57 teachers in the registry noted David Life in their bio

McGonigal, Kelly

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 4 teachers in the registry noted Kelly McGonigal in their bio

Miller, Elise Browning

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 16 teachers in the registry noted Elise Browning Miller in their bio

Miller, Tim

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 71 teachers in the registry noted Tim Miller in their bio

Mittra, Dharma

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 161 teachers in the registry noted Dharma Mittra in their bio

Mohan, A.G.

    • NOT Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 8 teachers in the registry noted A.G. Mohan in their bio

Nelson, Sonia

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 9 teachers in the registry noted Sonia Nelson in their bio

Paul, Russill

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 4 teachers in the registry noted Russill Paul in their bio

Ray, Kali

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 13 teachers in the registry noted Kali Ray in their bio

Raye, Saul David

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 28 teachers in the registry noted Saul David Raye in their bio

Ross, Steve

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 13 teachers in the registry noted Steve Ross in their bio

Schiffmann, Erich

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 48 teachers in the registry noted Erich Schiffmann in their bio

Schumacher, John

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 12 teachers in the registry noted John Schumacher in their bio

Stern, Eddie

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 20 teachers in the registry noted Eddie Stern in their bio

Swenson, David

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 169 teachers in the registry noted David Swenson in their bio

Vernon, Rama Jyoti

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 14 teachers in the registry noted Rama Jyoti Vernon in their bio

Walden, Patricia

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 40 teachers in the registry noted Patricia Walden in their bio

White, Ganga

    • Not Registered Oct 3, 2019
    • 32 teachers in the registry noted Ganga White in their bio

Other Teachers

Of course, it’s not only widely-known teachers who decline to register with Yoga Alliance. Here are some examples of teachers replying to a Facebook post to say that they are not registered with YA either.


Increasing Bureaucratic Burdens

Yoga Alliance does not provide significant resources to support increasing competency and instead burdens trainers with bureaucracy and fees, including an unusually high application fee.

As of February 2020, Yoga Alliance began charging trainers with responsibility for teacher competency (of unspecified standards) in more than 50 topics. And yet Yoga Alliance offers insignificant resources to support this process.

    1. Instead, it requires a burdensome application process with demanding documentation requirements, fees and processing time. (See here for more details.)
    2. While Yoga Alliance offers no standards or materials to support trainers in setting or meeting competency standards, they now demand submission of the trainer’s intellectual property (copyrighted syllabus and training curriculum plus their branded manual).
Standards vs Bureaucracy

Yoga Alliance drug out my application for nearly a year. They didn’t understand the quality or delivery process of my training and in the end I dumbed it down to the point it no longer resembled my training at all and simply told them what they wanted to hear.  – Sarcha Thurston  link


YA Truth & Rec

Since publishing Registration, Certification, Accreditation: Why You Don’t Need to Pay the Yoga Alliance Fees, emails from teachers and trainers came flooding in, expressing support and offering to volunteer to hold a transparent discussion about alternatives to Yoga Alliance. (A 39-member board was formed and was in effect in 2019. See here for their discussion topics and findings.)

Most of the teachers and trainers who have written in have expressed frustration with various issues and have given their support for more sharing of information. But there have also been some stories of experiences with Yoga Alliance that are describing a level of harm that seemed important to be brought to light. Below are some of those statements. Please write in if you have anything to share.

Bureaucracy, Not Standards

Overview

Yoga Alliance took almost a year to approve an RYS application submitted by a highly qualified teacher who had experience training with an elite teacher (Gregor Maehle). The same training program, submitted to Yoga Australia, was accepted immediately. Years prior, YA required this experienced teacher trainer to go through a basic training with a YA-registered school despite already training teachers for Maehle.

Statement

Yoga Australia has significantly higher standards than Yoga Alliance and usually processes most applications in around six months, after a close supportive process with the applicant. I submitted a training application to both Yoga Australia and Yoga Alliance. Yoga Australia approved the application within 48 hours without revision. Yoga Alliance drug out my application for nearly a year. They didn’t understand the quality or delivery process of my training and in the end, I dumbed it down to the point it no longer resembled my training at all and simply told them what they wanted to hear.

I am also a teacher who many years prior had to redo basic training to get registered with Yoga Alliance despite already training teachers for Gregor Maehle.

Yoga Alliance is structured to endorse training that maximises membership to the organisation rather than support robust standards in training and teaching. This, in my opinion, makes it purely a commercial enterprise entirely of zero value to teachers or trainers.

The organisation itself is mostly responsible for leading to a worldwide degradation of training standards in efforts to widen the potential membership net by allowing registration of 200-hour training that is delivered over very short time frames — as short as a few weeks. As a yoga school owner, I would never employ someone who trained for only a few weeks.  I think we would all agree that this is grossly inadequate, even for basic training. I can’t see them ever changing this as it would severely limit their membership pool.

Having achieved a widening of the membership net of the organisation, Yoga Alliance are moving towards monopolising power as demonstrated in their making the training registration process deliberately rigid,  unnecessarily long and complicated, and funneled.

By funneled, I mean that they only recognise the YA pathway – even though there are other organisations that do the same thing (and much better). If you don’t join the system at the bottom end, you are forever kept out of the system. I’d like to work to keep options open and to compare the standards that various organisations support.

Contact

Sarcha Thurston, Yoga Hub Perth

No Verification of Training Quality

Overview

Experienced trainers of high integrity have “witnessed people who could not teach a sun salutation or have even basic understandings of the principles of yogic philosophy, physiology or psychology that had been registered with YA.” Despite advanced training with elite teachers and philosophers, trainers will be required to undertake further training with YA “approved” schools.

Statement

My partner and I operate a small yoga studio in the suburbs of Detroit called House of Yoga. We have had difficulties with Yoga Alliance and essentially understand it to be a money making venture wrongly perceived to be an organization that upholds standards.

We also understand that virtually anyone can become a “certified yoga teacher” [the common understanding] through Yoga Alliance as they have no way of verifying what training an individual really has.

We both believe in high ethical and moral practices and believe in teaching people how to be really good, sincere teachers. We have witnessed people who could not teach a sun salutation or have even basic understandings of the principles of yogic philosophy, physiology or psychology that had been certified by YA.

We’ve thought about doing an experiment where we register our cat “Buddha” as a yoga teacher haha. If the fee was paid, there’s no reason to expect there would be a problem.

We have both been practicing and teaching for nearly 20 years and have led many, many teacher training programs. We are having difficulty with the new regulations by the YA that in order to continue to provide trainings, we will soon have to have an RYT-500. We both have had much training from the best Hatha Yoga teachers and spiritual teachers out there today…. real teachers such as Mark Whitwell and yogic scholars such as Russill Paul, among many others.

But the YA process doesn’t take into account such quality and requires that we train with their “approved” schools.

Contact

David Shiva Das & Durga Devi, House of Yoga Berkley, MI

No Consequences for Ethical Violation, Punished the Victim

Overview

Yoga Alliance did not provide any support or relief to a YA registered teacher who reported trainers who had misrepresented themselves as a registered school. YA did not acknowledge the training the teacher received and yet allowed the trainers who lied about their status to later register with no consequences. The teacher was afforded no relief for being victimized by the lie or for reporting the violation. YA did not warn other teachers of the ethical violation.

Update, January 2020: The yoga teacher who reported this event notified us that after this report was published here, Yoga Alliance remedied the situation. (Because the situation has been remedied, we have removed all identifying information from the statement below.) What great news that the teacher received justice. This is also an indication that if you have been harmed and choose to report the truth of what happened to you that you may be able to obtain restitution.

Statement

I am currently registered with Yoga Alliance as an E-RYT 200.

I  agree that the standards don’t represent teacher quality and that Yoga Alliance provides no real oversight of the standards.

I  wanted to share with you a personal experience that showed me that Yoga Alliance also provides no ethical oversight of their teachers and schools, despite their bragging about how they protect teachers and the Yoga community.

I enrolled in a 300-hour teacher training program run by two teachers who were E-RYT 500.  The enrollment material and program website advertised that it was a Yoga Alliance approved RYS-300.  Upon finishing the program,  I found out it was not.

I filed a grievance with Yoga Alliance, because mis-representing a program as an RYS is, of course, a violation of the Yoga Alliance rules. Essentially the two trainers running the program lied and took a ton of money under false pretenses, which is stealing.  The Yoga Alliance code of conduct requires all teachers and trainers to abide by the Yamas, which prohibit lying and stealing.

In response to my grievance, Yoga Alliance acknowledged that the school and trainers lied. But rather than doing anything to help me, they told me I needed to enroll in a new program and start all over again.!

And, instead of punishing the school and trainers, they let them pay the registration fee to become an RYS-300.

Yoga Alliance punished the victim and rewarded rule breakers who lied and stole.

I have copies of the 300 hour program’s letter of engagement and printouts about the program from their website. And I have the grievance correspondence with Yoga Alliance including their reply.

If Yoga Alliance had helped me, the victim, all they would have received is goodwill. But by helping the school they got 600 bucks and annual renewal money.

Thank you for your interest.

Self-Governance & Proposed Standards

The common misperceptions described above prompt some considerations:

  1. If you were previously under the impression that Yoga Alliance was a governance body or an enforcer of standards, you can consider the reality and draw conclusions from your perspective.
  2. You might choose to help those who are misinformed to know that Yoga Alliance is not a standards or governance body and that there is no industry-wide standard-bearer for yoga.

Each teacher and trainer may choose their own approach to this subject. Yoga Teacher Central takes the position that:

  1. The only wise and sustainable model for virtually anything is self-responsibility as opposed to policing by an outside authority.
  2. Real and true improvement is more likely to be successful with support and empowerment as opposed to bureaucracy.
  3. Thus, the information highlighted here is not meant to imply advocacy for outside or industry-wide governance. Rather, this is an effort to make more people aware that there’s a widespread misperception that governance and standards-enforcement exists when, in fact, it does not. With our eyes open to the facts, we’re better prepared to approach the subject of standards and improving industry-wide teaching competency.
  4. As of February 2021, Yoga Teacher Central offers Minimum Knowledge Standards for yoga teachers. We encourage adoption of these knowledge standards by yoga teaching professionals, and welcome feedback.

 


CONNECT WITH US

© 2021 Yoga Teacher Central • All rights reserved • Terms of service • Privacy policy